Direct answer
Keep a small selection of safe textures available and rotate one or two items at a time. Rotation can renew interest without relying on constant novelty or leaving too many choices out.
Offer fewer choices at once
Two or three different safe textures are usually easier to manage than a floor covered with every toy.
Rotate based on function
Keep one soothing chew, one interactive toy, and one quieter enrichment option. Swap items when interest falls.
Inspect during every rotation
Rotation is a built-in opportunity to clean toys and remove anything cracked, frayed, or too small.
What to avoid
Keep the response gentle.
Avoid creating constant novelty whenever the puppy walks away from a toy.
Safety boundary
When to get more help.
Dogs who guard toys need an individualized plan for safe access and exchanges.
References
Evidence and professional guidance
Related reading